Why a prescriber should understand psychotherapy

A prescriber who cannot tell therapy-shaped problems from medication-shaped ones will reach for the prescription every time.

For high-performing professionals in Chicago and Chicagoland: This article reflects clinical evidence and direct experience. If you're in the Chicago area or Illinois, contact me to discuss your concerns.

Much of outpatient psychiatry has narrowed to fifteen-minute medication reviews, with therapy referred out to someone else who the prescriber may never speak to. It is efficient and it is how most systems are built. It also produces a predictable failure.

What gets missed

If the only tool is medication, every presentation gets interpreted as a medication problem. Someone whose anxiety is maintained by avoidance will get a dose increase rather than a referral for exposure work — and the dose increase will not fix it, because avoidance is not responsive to serotonin.

Someone whose depression is driven by an unlivable situation gets treated for the depression while the situation continues. Someone with trauma that has never been processed cycles through agents for years.

None of those are medication failures. They are formulation failures.

What understanding therapy changes

A prescriber who knows what cognitive behavioural therapy actually involves can tell whether a patient has had it or has had supportive counselling described as CBT. They can tell whether a trauma therapy was an actual protocol or a sympathetic conversation.

They can also sequence properly: medication first when someone is too unwell to engage, therapy first when the problem is behavioural and the distress is tolerable, both together when the evidence supports it.

And it changes the appointment itself

Even a medication appointment is an interaction between two people, and what happens in it affects what gets disclosed. A prescriber with no training in how people avoid, minimise, or present themselves will take what is said at face value and prescribe accordingly.

Why I am training this way

Most psychiatric nurse practitioner students complete their clinical hours under another nurse practitioner. My 625 hours are arranged differently: 500 under a psychiatrist, and 125 specifically under a clinical psychologist to learn psychotherapy.

That is a harder route and it was deliberate. I would rather be a prescriber who understands what I am referring people to, and who can tell when the prescription is not the answer.

Published August 2026 · Reviewed for accuracy against the sources listed above.